Comment: I had asked a representative from Minitech if their CNC milling machine could machine silicon samples to a thickness of 30 micron with an accuracy of +- 1 micron, and he suggested that I should contact you as a Minitech user with first-hand knowledge of the CNC milling machine.
Reply: Hello,
Yes, the Minitech is capable of offering the precision of displacement required for what you're planning to do.
But I don't think that's where the real problem lies...
1) To fix the part... (How? Vacuum clamping? Microfreezing? Special hyper-fluid removable glue?
2) Make the perfect tilts to guarantee the // of the part's reference surface in relation to the machine's G17 plane.
Yes, the Minitech's 4th and 5th axes are probably capable of offering sufficient tilting precision for this purpose, but will the system be sufficiently rigid for the cutting method used?
3) That for this kind of job, I had to equip the Minitech with a touch probe system that meets (Unidirectional Repeatability max. 1 μm (2 Sigma) with 16 mm stylus and 254 mm/min probing federate). For measurement purposes.
Afterwards... How will the part behave under the cutting force...? Which tools to use (diamond)? Certainly. But what about the cutting force...?
Wouldn't it be safer to equip the Minitech with an 80K Rpm spindle and use diamond micro wheels? It's hard to say without extensive testing.
The Minitech is exceptional in terms of precision. I guarantee it.
But even with the best machine in the world, not everything is possible.
But that's the kind of challenge I like to take up.
And now I don't want to do my research work without my Minitech.
Best regards.
Stéphane Louis
Sirris
www.sirris.be/en/industrial-lab/micromanufacturing
Reply: Hello,
Yes, the Minitech is capable of offering the precision of displacement required for what you're planning to do.
But I don't think that's where the real problem lies...
1) To fix the part... (How? Vacuum clamping? Microfreezing? Special hyper-fluid removable glue?
2) Make the perfect tilts to guarantee the // of the part's reference surface in relation to the machine's G17 plane.
Yes, the Minitech's 4th and 5th axes are probably capable of offering sufficient tilting precision for this purpose, but will the system be sufficiently rigid for the cutting method used?
3) That for this kind of job, I had to equip the Minitech with a touch probe system that meets (Unidirectional Repeatability max. 1 μm (2 Sigma) with 16 mm stylus and 254 mm/min probing federate). For measurement purposes.
Afterwards... How will the part behave under the cutting force...? Which tools to use (diamond)? Certainly. But what about the cutting force...?
Wouldn't it be safer to equip the Minitech with an 80K Rpm spindle and use diamond micro wheels? It's hard to say without extensive testing.
The Minitech is exceptional in terms of precision. I guarantee it.
But even with the best machine in the world, not everything is possible.
But that's the kind of challenge I like to take up.
And now I don't want to do my research work without my Minitech.
Best regards.
Stéphane Louis
Sirris
www.sirris.be/en/industrial-lab/micromanufacturing
Question: How does a Minitech machine compare to a Haas?
Answer:
The Minitech CNC micromilling machine and Haas machines belong to different categories of CNC milling machines, and they have distinct features and capabilities. Here are some points to consider when comparing the two:
Answer:
The Minitech CNC micromilling machine and Haas machines belong to different categories of CNC milling machines, and they have distinct features and capabilities. Here are some points to consider when comparing the two:
- Size and Capacity: Minitech CNC micromilling machines are typically smaller in size and designed for precise, intricate milling tasks on small-scale workpieces. On the other hand, Haas machines are generally larger and capable of handling a wider range of milling applications, including larger workpieces and heavy-duty cutting.
- Precision and Accuracy: Minitech micromilling machines are known for their high precision and accuracy, making them suitable for microscale milling tasks that demand fine details. Haas machines also offer excellent precision but are typically used for broader applications that may not require the same level of micro-scale precision.
- Speed and Power: Haas machines are known for their high-speed machining capabilities and robust cutting power. They are designed to handle demanding machining tasks efficiently and quickly. While Minitech micromilling machines can achieve high precision, they may not offer the same level of speed and power as Haas machines.
- Cost: Haas machines are generally more expensive than Minitech micromilling machines. This price difference reflects the disparity in size, capacity, and capabilities between the two types of machines.
Qustion: How does a Minitech compare to a Taig or Sherline??
Comparison Report: Minitech vs. Taig vs. Sherline CNC Machines
Introduction: This report aims to provide a brief comparison of the Minitech, Taig, and Sherline CNC machines. These machines are popular choices in the realm of small-scale CNC milling and offer various features and capabilities. The comparison will focus on key aspects such as size, precision, versatility, and price to assist potential buyers in making an informed decision.
1 Size:
Minitech: The Minitech CNC machines are known for their compact size, making them suitable for limited workspace or portable applications.
Taig: Taig CNC machines are also compact and offer a smaller footprint, which can be advantageous for those with space constraints.
Sherline: Sherline CNC machines are similarly compact and designed to fit well in small workshop setups.
2 Precision:
Minitech: Minitech machines are acclaimed for their exceptional high precision and accuracy, enabling intricate and detailed milling operations.
Taig: Taig machines are known for their hobby-grade precision, allowing for accurate machining of small parts.
Sherline: Sherline machines offer good precision, suitable for a range of small to medium-sized milling projects.
3 Versatility:
Minitech: Minitech CNC machines are versatile and can handle various materials, making them suitable for industries like high-end jewelry making, medical devices, prototyping, and microelectronics.
Taig: Taig machines are versatile as well, accommodating diverse milling tasks across different industries. Sherline: Sherline machines are versatile and can be utilized for a wide array of milling applications, making them suitable for hobbyists, model makers, and small-scale production.
4. Price:
Minitech: Minitech CNC machines are generally priced in the higher range due to their exceptional precision and specialized capabilities.
Taig: Taig machines are competitively priced, offering good value for the precision and features they provide.
Sherline: Sherline machines are also priced competitively, making them an attractive option for those seeking affordability without compromising quality.
Conclusion:
In summary, the Minitech, Taig, and Sherline CNC machines each have their unique strengths. The Minitech machines stand out for their exceptional precision and suitability for intricate milling tasks. Taig machines offer a balance of precision, versatility, and competitive pricing. Sherline machines are known for their compact size, versatility, and affordability. The choice between these machines ultimately depends on individual requirements, the scale of projects, and budget constraints.
Potential buyers should carefully evaluate their specific needs, considering factors such as precision requirements, available workspace, and intended applications. It is advisable to conduct further research and consult with industry experts or users to make an informed decision based on individual preferences.
Disclaimer: This report provides a general comparison and is not an exhaustive analysis of all features and specifications of Minitech, Taig, and Sherline CNC machines. Buyers are encouraged to refer to detailed product information and consult with manufacturers or authorized distributors for precise and up-to-date specifications.
Comparison Report: Minitech vs. Taig vs. Sherline CNC Machines
Introduction: This report aims to provide a brief comparison of the Minitech, Taig, and Sherline CNC machines. These machines are popular choices in the realm of small-scale CNC milling and offer various features and capabilities. The comparison will focus on key aspects such as size, precision, versatility, and price to assist potential buyers in making an informed decision.
1 Size:
Minitech: The Minitech CNC machines are known for their compact size, making them suitable for limited workspace or portable applications.
Taig: Taig CNC machines are also compact and offer a smaller footprint, which can be advantageous for those with space constraints.
Sherline: Sherline CNC machines are similarly compact and designed to fit well in small workshop setups.
2 Precision:
Minitech: Minitech machines are acclaimed for their exceptional high precision and accuracy, enabling intricate and detailed milling operations.
Taig: Taig machines are known for their hobby-grade precision, allowing for accurate machining of small parts.
Sherline: Sherline machines offer good precision, suitable for a range of small to medium-sized milling projects.
3 Versatility:
Minitech: Minitech CNC machines are versatile and can handle various materials, making them suitable for industries like high-end jewelry making, medical devices, prototyping, and microelectronics.
Taig: Taig machines are versatile as well, accommodating diverse milling tasks across different industries. Sherline: Sherline machines are versatile and can be utilized for a wide array of milling applications, making them suitable for hobbyists, model makers, and small-scale production.
4. Price:
Minitech: Minitech CNC machines are generally priced in the higher range due to their exceptional precision and specialized capabilities.
Taig: Taig machines are competitively priced, offering good value for the precision and features they provide.
Sherline: Sherline machines are also priced competitively, making them an attractive option for those seeking affordability without compromising quality.
Conclusion:
In summary, the Minitech, Taig, and Sherline CNC machines each have their unique strengths. The Minitech machines stand out for their exceptional precision and suitability for intricate milling tasks. Taig machines offer a balance of precision, versatility, and competitive pricing. Sherline machines are known for their compact size, versatility, and affordability. The choice between these machines ultimately depends on individual requirements, the scale of projects, and budget constraints.
Potential buyers should carefully evaluate their specific needs, considering factors such as precision requirements, available workspace, and intended applications. It is advisable to conduct further research and consult with industry experts or users to make an informed decision based on individual preferences.
Disclaimer: This report provides a general comparison and is not an exhaustive analysis of all features and specifications of Minitech, Taig, and Sherline CNC machines. Buyers are encouraged to refer to detailed product information and consult with manufacturers or authorized distributors for precise and up-to-date specifications.
Date: July 26, 2023
From: Toshko Ivanov (https://www.facebook.com/toshko.ivanov.148)
Comment/Question: Put the price morons
Response:
Toshko Ivanov, We apologize if you had trouble finding our pricing information on our website. We understand that transparency is important, and we strive to provide all necessary details to our customers.
We would like to clarify that we do indeed list our prices on our website. We have a dedicated pricing page where you can find comprehensive information about our products and services, including their respective costs. We aim to make it easy for our customers to access this information and make informed decisions.
If you encountered any difficulties locating our pricing page, we apologize for the inconvenience. Please let us know, and we'll be more than happy to assist you in finding the information you need. Our customer support team is available to answer any questions you may have.
We value your feedback and appreciate your interest in our products. Should you require any further assistance, please don't hesitate to reach out to us directly.
PRICING: https://www.minitech.com/2023-price-list.html#/
RFQ:https://www.minitech.com/rfq---request-for-price-quote...
RFQ - Lab Series: https://www.minitech.com/rfq---sls-micromills.html#/
From: Toshko Ivanov (https://www.facebook.com/toshko.ivanov.148)
Comment/Question: Put the price morons
Response:
Toshko Ivanov, We apologize if you had trouble finding our pricing information on our website. We understand that transparency is important, and we strive to provide all necessary details to our customers.
We would like to clarify that we do indeed list our prices on our website. We have a dedicated pricing page where you can find comprehensive information about our products and services, including their respective costs. We aim to make it easy for our customers to access this information and make informed decisions.
If you encountered any difficulties locating our pricing page, we apologize for the inconvenience. Please let us know, and we'll be more than happy to assist you in finding the information you need. Our customer support team is available to answer any questions you may have.
We value your feedback and appreciate your interest in our products. Should you require any further assistance, please don't hesitate to reach out to us directly.
PRICING: https://www.minitech.com/2023-price-list.html#/
RFQ:https://www.minitech.com/rfq---request-for-price-quote...
RFQ - Lab Series: https://www.minitech.com/rfq---sls-micromills.html#/
Minitech Machinery Corp. 6050 Peachtree Parkway Suite 240-205 Norcross, Georgia 30092 USA(770) 441-8525 [email protected] |
|